It was drink, eat, drink, eat, drink eat, etc. and be merry at the Shafer and Joseph Phelps wine dinner, held by ASC Fine Wines at Aria on November 10. I know little about wine, other than being able to visually discern between red, white and rose, but here's my two renminbi.
We started with Bollinger Special Cuvee Champagne, followed by Phelps' Los Carneros Chardonnay 2002, which Doug Shafer , president of the winery and in attendance, called “ big, fat and rich ” (which isn't an uncommon way to describe wine: try plugging those words in to Yahoo.) Next, a Shafer Merlot 2002 that Doug described as “yummy” and a “pretty rich full wine that reflects the weather [where the grapes were grown].” This did have a nice nose and with two solid wines and some Champers under out belts, we were ready to trek into the sacred land of California's top “cabs” as some like to call Cabernet Sauvignons.
We next tasted, side by side, Phelps Insignia Napa Valley 1997 and 2001. In my notes I scribbled “vigorous, solid, full-bodied – Halle Berry in a tasteful black cocktail dress” and “this is a killer – Campbell Thompson .” Campbell works at ASC and was sitting beside me, thought I can't guarantee that he actually said those words. (By the way, does he not have a name that deserves a royal title, such as Sir Campbell Thompson or The Right Honorable Campbell Thompson or Campbell Thompson, Earl of ASC ? I'm telling you, there's nobility just waiting to happen there.)
If Campbell didn't say it, then I will: This wine is a killer . It was beautiful, with a nose that made you want to squeeze your head into the glass. It made the 2001 which came after it and which in other circumstances would probably have been the star seem like a slightly unready debutante ( could I sound any more pompous? ). Next up and, again, side by side were the Shafer Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 1997 and 2001. These wines, highly regarded by experts, seemed to be a bit of a letdown after the Phelps Insignia. An attendee astutely asked, “Were the Shafer wines disadvantaged being served with the steak course rather than the cheese course ?” They were and it's too bad, but I guess two slabs of meat weren't in order. Around that time, according to my notes, Doug uttered the words “ I'ma big ass Cabernet and I'm here to see you ,” but I have no idea of the context. Anyway, we finished off with a Joseph Phelps Late Harvest Riesling 1993 (which I can sum up in one word – sweet) and I then bucked down two glasses of Bollinger for good measure.
As for the dinner, it was good, although it required some dictionary research ( remoulade : a piquant cold sauce made with mayonnaise, chopped pickles, capers, anchovies, and herbs; quince : the fruit of a central Asian tree of the rose family that resembles a hard-fleshed yellow apple and is used esp. in preserves; and so on).
This wine dinner cost RMB988 and was excellent value, with a good combination of food, drink and interesting patrons. For number crunchers, just consider that a bottle of Shafer Hillside would set you back at least USD350 (www.winesearcher.com – thanks to Campbell for the site reference). For all others, consider that man cannot live on Taillan Malbec alone. Speaking of which…
(From Beijing Boyce IV, first emailed on November 18, 2005)
